safe to fail
It’s a risk to empower humanity with this kind of freedom. Consequences, mistakes, and disasters are always a possibility. Maybe it’s the fear of risk that drives us to Omnipotence in the first place. If things go poorly, we’re absolvable. After all, we shrug, God is the only one with access to “the blueprint,” so it must have been a part of the plan. Then we gather en masse, in church, in mass to bow our knees: less for worship, more for placing them on the giant neck of risk, binding it over and over like Lilliputians using ropes to tie down the giant Gulliver.
Not that I am innocent of such bindings. In the face of risk, facing the risk of whether to love again after incalculable loss, I have sung about or prayed to a God of control or a God in control, in an effort to quell my sense of being thoroughly out of control. But there is nothing airtight about this approach. I can no longer vouch for failsafe Omnipotent religions, only religions where it’s safe to fail. If what was written to the Corinthians is true—that is, that endings consist of faith, hope, and love—then surely beginnings consist of risk, question, and vulnerability. Endings are constantly flowing into beginnings; apocalyptic unveilings amid tehomic and fluid beginning. And so it goes.
Not long ago, I was in a setting full of good people—how else to describe this bunch? Maybe in certain contexts, we would call them “real salt of the earth” folks, people accustomed to giving their time, resources, and devotion. As they prepared to hear a message (unfortunately for them, I was the speaker), we sang a song. I don’t know the name of the tune, but I can guarantee that at the very least, the title contained the word “control.” I tried to join with the good people, I really did, but instead of singing, I found myself counting the number of times that word was vocalized. I forget the tally now: ten? twenty? forty? If the word control had been a bullet, I would have been shot multiple times over that morning. By the end of the song, I was closing my eyes. I suppose the congregants may have assumed I was in prayer. True enough. I was praying. But not in celebration of control; rather, in the patient inner work of clothing myself with armor (of the Lord?) as I did my best to defend myself against the onslaught.
From Theology of Consent: Mimetic Theory in an Open and Relational Universe by Jonathan J. Foster (SacraSage Press, 2022), chapter II:1 The Universe in the Key of Relationality. Quoted with the author's permission.
Buy Theology of Consent on Amazon →
Close this page to return to your phrase in Embering.
Jonathan Foster’s phrases arrive one a day in Embering, a quiet app for reading a single phrase and letting it settle.
Get Embering