← Jonathan Foster
Theology of Consent

strong humans

II:1 The Universe in the Key of Relationality · p. 90 · 2022

Additionally, if the point were to eradicate risk, what is faith? And if the point were for us to blindly trust an Omnipotent, blueprint-following God, wouldn’t it be sinful, not to mention impossible, to oppose the blueprint? If God wills an injustice, what are we poor humans to do? Such logic puts us in an untenable situation of resisting evil while acknowledging evil as indispensable to God’s plan.

It seems reasonable to suggest that people who have religious faith must have respect for risk but also for their own ability to navigate that risk. To be enthralled with God, to place God “on a pedestal,” to appeal to the one-masculine-separate-power-existing-outside-time-and-space to remove the risk, is to relegate ourselves into a blessed state of inaction. I’m not advocating for a weak God here; I’m advocating for strong humans. And I take my cue from that strong human, Jesus, who doesn’t seem to be interested in getting his friends to absolve themselves, or acquiesce, or comply, or conform. On the contrary, it appears he’s interested in stoking fires of agency and responsibility.

Consider Mark’s Jesus, who in usual terse Mark language, after being awakened from the storm says, “Why are you such cowards (deiloi )? Don’t you have any faith at all?” Apparently, according to Mark, Jesus felt strongly that his friends were more than capable of managing the crisis themselves, that they possessed power in themselves to meet the challenge. They were, after all, fisherman not unacquainted with storms on the Sea of Galilee. Instead, these capable men, chose not only to awaken the rabbi, but also to accuse him of being unconcerned with their welfare. (E.g., “Teacher is it nothing to you that we were going to drown?”) The result is a very grumpy Jesus. He offers the rebuke and appears to be saying, “You can do this. Remember this next time because I’m not always going to be here.”

From Theology of Consent: Mimetic Theory in an Open and Relational Universe by Jonathan J. Foster (SacraSage Press, 2022), chapter II:1 The Universe in the Key of Relationality. Quoted with the author's permission.

Buy Theology of Consent on Amazon →

← safe to failif your god is a hammer →

Close this page to return to your phrase in Embering.

Jonathan Foster’s phrases arrive one a day in Embering, a quiet app for reading a single phrase and letting it settle.

Get Embering