← Jonathan Foster
Theology of Consent

it simply insists

II:1 The Universe in the Key of Relationality · p. 78 · 2022

Like a non-native plant taking over a garden such that an observer might not even recognize its totalitarian demands, so an invasive word like Omnipotence has taken over capital-T TRUTH. In this garden: that is, the garden ruled by Omnipotence, anything approaching what might be considered aleatory must be weeded out. How could it be any other way, they presuppose, when God stands outside of time, operates by a universal blueprint, and is perfectly in control? Similarly, when Omnipotence (i.e., TRUTH) places prohibitions around the idea of a deeply connected and relational universe, it makes sense. How could it be any other way, they naturally ask, when God is perfect, impassible, and all-powerful?

However, a type of lowercase-t truth persists, or in Caputo’s language, “insists.” Lowercase-t truth doesn’t argue the existence of God; even more, it doesn’t argue for anything. Rather, it simply insists. Its insistence is revealed in the dissipation of waves upon the shore. In heartbeats arrested in prose. In the midnight depths of falling snow. In the echo of a name, the periphery of a sunset, the wound from a friend. In a whisper. In a prayer. In a first kiss. In the very last kiss. In parents carefully laying sleeping children in their beds; in parents carefully laying sleeping children in the snow, deep as a grave.

This lowercase-t truth insists in the logic of love, which everyone knows, is no logic at all. And quietly, paradoxically—my point—it insists deep within the injunctions and prohibitions of TRUTH.

From Theology of Consent: Mimetic Theory in an Open and Relational Universe by Jonathan J. Foster (SacraSage Press, 2022), chapter II:1 The Universe in the Key of Relationality. Quoted with the author's permission.

Buy Theology of Consent on Amazon →

← already in the canyonsafe to fail →

Close this page to return to your phrase in Embering.

Jonathan Foster’s phrases arrive one a day in Embering, a quiet app for reading a single phrase and letting it settle.

Get Embering