Letter 7
Rome, 14 May 1904
My dear Mr Kappus,
Much time has passed since I received your last letter. Do not hold it against me; first it was work, then interruptions and finally ill health that kept me again and again from this answer, which (as I wanted it) was to come to you out of quiet and good days. Now I feel a little better again (the beginning of spring, with its wicked, capricious changes, was hard to bear here too), and I come to greet you, dear Mr Kappus, and to tell you (which I do so gladly) this and that in reply to your letter, as well as I know how.
You see: I have copied out your sonnet, because I found that it is beautiful and simple, and born in the form in which it moves with such quiet decorum. It is the best of the verses of yours that I have been allowed to read. And now I give you this copy, because I know that it is important and full of new experience to find one's own work again in someone else's handwriting. Read the verses as though they were someone else's, and you will feel in your innermost self how much they are your own.
It was a joy to me to read this sonnet and your letter often; I thank you for both.
And you must not let yourself be confused in your solitude by the fact that there is something in you that wishes to get out of it. Precisely this wish, if you use it calmly and deliberately, like a tool, will help you to spread your solitude out over wide country. People have (with the help of conventions) solved everything in the direction of the easy, and toward the easiest side of the easy; but it is clear that we must hold to what is difficult. Everything alive holds to it; everything in nature grows and defends itself in its own way, and is something of its own out of itself, tries to be so at any price and against all resistance. We know little, but that we must hold to what is difficult is a certainty that will not leave us. It is good to be solitary, for solitude is difficult; that something is difficult must be one more reason for us to do it.
To love is good, too, for love is difficult. For one human being to love another: that is perhaps the most difficult thing we have been given, the utmost, the final test and trial, the work for which all other work is only preparation.
That is why young people, who are beginners in everything, cannot yet love: they must learn it. With their whole being, with all their strength, gathered around their solitary, anxious, upward-beating heart, they must learn to love.
But a time of learning is always a long, secluded time, and so loving, for a long while ahead and far into life, is solitude, a heightened and deepened aloneness for the one who loves. Loving, at first, is nothing that means merging, surrendering and uniting with another (for what would a union be of what is unclarified and unfinished, still unordered?); it is a sublime occasion for the individual to ripen, to become something in himself, to become world, to become world for himself for the sake of another; it is a great, immodest claim upon him, something that singles him out and calls him to far things. Only in this sense, as the task of working on themselves ("to listen and to hammer day and night"), might young people use the love that is given to them. Merging and surrendering and every kind of togetherness is not for them (they must still save and gather for a long, long time); it is the final thing, perhaps that for which human lives are as yet scarcely sufficient.
But this is where young people so often and so gravely go wrong: they (whose nature it is to have no patience) fling themselves at each other when love comes over them, scatter themselves just as they are, in all their untidiness, disorder, confusion… And what then? What is life to do with this heap of half-broken things that they call their togetherness, and would like to call their happiness, if that were possible, and their future? Then each loses himself for the sake of the other, and loses the other, and many others who still wanted to come. And loses the wide spaces and the possibilities, exchanges the approach and flight of quiet, intimating things for a barren helplessness out of which nothing more can come; nothing but a little disgust, disappointment and poverty, and the escape into one of the many conventions that are set up in great numbers, like public shelters, along this most dangerous of roads. No area of human experience is so supplied with conventions as this one: there are life belts of the most varied invention, boats and swimming bladders; society's view has known how to create refuges of every kind, for since it was inclined to take love life as an amusement, it also had to fashion it to be easy, cheap, safe and secure, as public amusements are.
It is true that many young people who love wrongly, that is, simply surrendering and without solitude (the average will always stay at that), feel the oppressiveness of a failure, and want to make the state they have got into viable and fruitful in their own, personal way; for their nature tells them that the questions of love, even less than everything else that is important, cannot be solved publicly and according to this or that agreement; that they are questions, close questions from one human being to another, which in every case need a new, particular, wholly personal answer. But how could they, who have already flung themselves together and no longer mark their limits or tell themselves apart, who therefore no longer possess anything of their own, find a way out of themselves, out of the depth of a solitude already buried?
They act out of shared helplessness, and if, with the best will in the world, they then try to avoid the convention that strikes them (marriage, say), they fall into the tentacles of a less noisy but equally deadly conventional solution; for then everything, far around them, is convention. Where people act out of a murky togetherness that flowed together too early, every action is conventional: every relationship to which such confusion leads has its convention, however unusual (that is, in the ordinary sense, immoral) it may be; indeed, even separation would be a conventional step there, an impersonal decision of chance, without strength and without fear.
Whoever looks seriously finds that, as for death, which is difficult, so for difficult love no explanation, no solution, neither hint nor path has yet been found; and for these two tasks, which we carry veiled and pass on without opening them, no common rule resting on agreement will be discovered. But in the same measure as we begin, as individuals, to attempt life, these great things will meet us, the individuals, at closer range. The demands that the difficult work of love makes on our development are larger than life, and as beginners we are not equal to them. But if we endure all the same and take this love upon us as a burden and an apprenticeship, instead of losing ourselves in all the light and frivolous play behind which people have hidden from the most serious seriousness of their existence, then a small advance and an easing will perhaps be felt by those who come long after us; that would be much.
For we are only just beginning to look at the relationship of one individual to a second individual objectively and without prejudice, and our attempts to live such a relationship have no model before them. And yet in the changes of the time there is already much that wants to help our timid beginnings.
The girl and the woman, in their new, own unfolding, will only for a time be imitators of male bad habits and ways, and repeaters of male professions. After the uncertainty of such transitions it will become clear that women have gone through the abundance and variety of those (often ridiculous) disguises only in order to cleanse their own most essential being of the distorting influences of the other sex. Women, in whom life lingers and dwells more directly, more fruitfully and more trustingly, must at bottom have become riper human beings, more human human beings, than the light man, who is not pulled down beneath the surface of life by the weight of any bodily fruit, and who, conceited and hasty, underestimates what he thinks he loves. This humanity of woman, carried to term in pain and humiliation, will come to light when she has stripped off the conventions of mere femininity in the transformations of her outward station, and the men who do not yet feel it coming today will be surprised and struck by it.
One day (and there are already reliable signs of this speaking and shining, especially in the northern countries), one day there will be the girl and the woman whose name will no longer mean only the opposite of the male, but something in itself, something in which one thinks of no complement and no limit, only of life and existence: the female human being.
This advance will transform the experience of love, which is now full of error (very much against the will of the outdistanced men at first), change it from the ground up, and reshape it into a relationship meant from one human being to another, no longer from man to woman. And this more human love (which will be accomplished infinitely considerately and quietly, and well and clearly in binding and releasing) will resemble the love we are preparing, struggling and with effort: the love that consists in this, that two solitudes protect, border and greet each other.
And this too: do not believe that the great love which was once laid upon you as a boy was lost; can you say whether great and good wishes did not ripen in you then, and resolutions by which you still live today? I believe that that love remains so strong and powerful in your memory because it was your first deep being-alone and the first inner work you did on your life. All good wishes to you, dear Mr Kappus!
Yours,
Rainer Maria Rilke
With this letter Rilke enclosed his copy of Kappus's sonnet. It is Kappus's own poem and is not reproduced here.
Translated from the German for Embering. The original, Briefe an einen jungen Dichter (1929), is in the public domain. Read it in German.
Close this page to return to your line in Embering.
Rilke's lines arrive one a day in Embering, a quiet app for reading a single line slowly.
Get Embering