Letter 3
Viareggio, near Pisa (Italy), 23 April 1903
You have given me much joy, dear and esteemed Sir, with your Easter letter; for it said many good things of you, and the way you spoke of Jacobsen's great and beloved art showed me that I was not wrong when I led your life, with its many questions, to this abundance.
Now Niels Lyhne will open itself to you, a book of splendours and depths; the more often one reads it, the more it seems that everything is in it, from life's faintest fragrance to the full, rich taste of its heaviest fruits. There is nothing in it that has not been understood, grasped, lived through and recognised in the trembling after-echo of memory; no experience has been too slight, and the smallest event unfolds like a destiny, and destiny itself is like a wonderful, wide fabric in which every thread is guided by an infinitely tender hand, laid beside another, and held and carried by a hundred others. You will know the great happiness of reading this book for the first time, and will go through its countless surprises as if in a new dream. But I can tell you that even later one goes through these books again and again with the same astonishment, and that they lose nothing of their wonderful power and give up nothing of the enchantment with which they overwhelm the reader the first time.
One only comes to enjoy them more and more, to be more and more grateful, and somehow better and simpler in one's seeing, deeper in one's faith in life, and in life more blessed and greater.
And later you must read the wonderful book of the fate and longing of Marie Grubbe, and Jacobsen's letters and journal pages and fragments, and finally his verses, which (even if they are only moderately well translated) live on in endless resonance. (For this I would advise you to buy, when you have the chance, the lovely complete edition of Jacobsen's works, which contains all of these. It was published in three volumes, well translated, by Eugen Diederichs in Leipzig, and costs, I believe, only five or six marks a volume.)
In your opinion of There Should Have Been Roses… (that work of such incomparable delicacy and form) you are of course quite, quite unassailably right, against the man who wrote the introduction. And let me make a request here at once: read as little as possible of aesthetic criticism. Such things are either partisan views, petrified and grown meaningless in their lifeless hardening, or they are clever plays on words, in which one view wins today and the opposite one tomorrow.
Works of art are of an infinite solitude, and nothing reaches them so little as criticism. Only love can grasp them and hold them, and be just to them.
Each time, give yourself and your feeling the right, against any such discussion, review or introduction; should you be wrong after all, the natural growth of your inner life will lead you, slowly and in time, to other insights. Leave your judgements their own quiet, undisturbed development, which, like all progress, must come from deep within and can be neither pressed nor hurried by anything. Everything is carrying to term and then giving birth. To let each impression and each seed of a feeling come to completion wholly within oneself, in the dark, in the unsayable, the unconscious, beyond the reach of one's own understanding, and to wait with deep humility and patience for the hour when a new clarity is born: that alone is what it means to live as an artist, in understanding as in creating.
There is no measuring with time there; no year counts, and ten years are nothing. Being an artist means not calculating and counting; it means ripening like the tree that does not force its sap, and stands at ease in the storms of spring without fear that no summer may follow. It comes. But it comes only to the patient, who are there as if eternity lay before them, so carefree, still and wide. I learn it every day, learn it through pains to which I am grateful: patience is everything!
Richard Dehmel: with his books (and, by the way, with the man too, whom I know slightly), I find that whenever I have found one of his beautiful pages, I am always afraid of the next, which may destroy everything again and turn what is lovable into something unworthy. You have characterised him very well with the phrase "living and writing in heat". And in fact the artist's experience lies so unbelievably close to the sexual, to its pain and its pleasure, that the two are really only different forms of one and the same longing and bliss. And if instead of "heat" one could say "sex", sex in the great, wide, pure sense, not made suspect by any error of the Church, then his art would be very great and infinitely important. His poetic power is great, and strong as a primal instinct; it has its own ruthless rhythms in it and breaks out of him as if out of mountains.
But it seems that this power is not always wholly sincere and without pose. (But this is also one of the hardest trials for the one who creates: he must always remain unaware, unsuspecting of his best virtues, if he does not want to rob them of their ingenuousness and innocence!) And then, where it comes rushing through his being to the sexual, it does not find a person quite as pure as it needs. There is no fully mature and pure world of sex there, but one that is not human enough, that is only male, is heat, intoxication and restlessness, and burdened with the old prejudices and arrogance with which man has disfigured and burdened love. Because he loves only as a man, not as a human being, there is something narrow in his sexual feeling, something seemingly wild, spiteful, time-bound, unlasting, which diminishes his art and makes it ambiguous and doubtful. It is not without stain; it is marked by its time and by passion, and little of it will last and endure. (But most art is like that!) Even so, one can take deep joy in what is great in it, only one must not get lost in it and become an adherent of that world of Dehmel's, which is so infinitely anxious, full of adultery and confusion, and far from the real destinies, which cause more suffering than these passing troubles, but also give more occasion for greatness and more courage for eternity.
Finally, as for my books, I would most like to send you all of them that might give you any pleasure. But I am very poor, and my books, once they have appeared, no longer belong to me. I cannot buy them myself and give them, as I so often wish to, to those who would be kind to them.
So I am writing down for you on a slip of paper the titles (and publishers) of my most recent books (the newest; in all I have published perhaps 12 or 13), and must leave it to you, dear Sir, to order something from it now and then.
I am glad to know my books are with you.
Farewell!
Yours,
Rainer Maria Rilke
Translated from the German for Embering. The original, Briefe an einen jungen Dichter (1929), is in the public domain. Read it in German.
Close this page to return to your line in Embering.
Rilke's lines arrive one a day in Embering, a quiet app for reading a single line slowly.
Get Embering