← Jonathan Foster
Theology of Consent

to walk away

II:2 Indeterminacy and All Her Friends · p. 118 · 2022

Many open and relational thinkers are suspicious that creation ex nihilo cycles us back to a top-down, Omnipotent-Religion; one that presupposes a type of separateness between God and creation. And while it goes beyond our scope to adequately detail what other approaches to creation might be, the point here is to inject suspicion into the theory of such a God existing, and then to align ourselves with a relational God. “The idea of a creation from nothing, rather than a formation from formlessness,” as Keller points out, “only gradually ensconced itself in Christian common sense. Along with it settled the dogmas of omnipotence: not just of the biblical lord of great if somewhat unpredictable power, but an immutable, unilateral All-Power clothed in the attributes of a single male Person (or two; or …).

To begin to see the chaos and complexity of tohu wa bohu is to live at the edge of the risky kingdom fueled by relational power such that the king is less authority and more brother or sister. Maybe a better term, as Tripp Fuller has proposed, is “kindom” for the risky kingdom is more like kin—that is family—than a group of people ruled by an independent and Omnipotent political sovereign. Yes, risky, but very interesting, for it paves the way for the possibility of love. If everything ran with clock-like certainty, then there would be no reason to risk. Love involves freedom, freedom involves choice, and choice presupposes risk. Love isn’t love unless it allows the other to walk away. If God is love, it follows that God doesn’t control—moreover cannot control.

What we might see here is strength in weakness, winning in losing, living in dying; the fabric of the universe threaded in counterintuitive and upside-down ways. It’s in both the micro and the macro, living in the particular individual constituents, within the relationship of those constituents, and in the larger amalgamation of those constituents. Indeterminacy throbs and pulsates through the nexus of this uncontrolling love resulting in a future not fully predictable or foreknown, even by God.

From Theology of Consent: Mimetic Theory in an Open and Relational Universe by Jonathan J. Foster (SacraSage Press, 2022), chapter II:2 Indeterminacy and All Her Friends. Quoted with the author's permission.

Buy Theology of Consent on Amazon →

← let it bethe buoyancy of love →

Close this page to return to your phrase in Embering.

Jonathan Foster’s phrases arrive one a day in Embering, a quiet app for reading a single phrase and letting it settle.

Get Embering