let it be
Open and relational theology is happy to locate itself in counterrhythms, and nuanced gradations, and messiahs living “in the gray”—and in the process become a spoke inserted into the wheel of an anxious and insecure religion. It’s a wheel that keeps rolling, not unlike the wheel of injustice, over those who do not bow down to hierarchy. None of this is done to fiendishly launch those riding the wheels of Omnipotence into the air, but to seriously wrestle with the implications of a relational universe. The disruption creates space for more nuanced ways to consider a pre-creation environment—where creation is understood as our known universe—that’s defined neither by evil nor sterility but by vibrancy and longing for intimacy.
All this could foreshadow how the Spirit interacts with Mary to bring forth new life in the first chapter of Luke. And in Mary’s consent, “Let it be,” we could see the necessary condition of all creation: that is, that God doesn’t force himself upon anyone. It seems both Luke 1 and Genesis 1 speak to a God interested in life that emerges through consensual intimacy. Consensual intimacy thwarts dominant theology’s efforts to equate God with power. And its corollary, which winds up equating the powerful with God such that those who fall short of power—those who, as Keller puts it, “wear the mark of chaos, the skins of darkness, the genders of unspeakable openings—those Others of Order …” —are powerless and far from God.
Life itself needs anomalies, chaos, difference, fluidity. Stars exploding create galaxies. Leaves decomposing create forests. Cells dividing create growth. Without the tension of tohu wa bohu there is no movement. Without movement there is no resolution. “Chaos,” as Whitehead says, “is not to be identified with evil; for harmony requires the due coordination of chaos, vagueness, narrowness, and width.”
From Theology of Consent: Mimetic Theory in an Open and Relational Universe by Jonathan J. Foster (SacraSage Press, 2022), chapter II:2 Indeterminacy and All Her Friends. Quoted with the author's permission.
Buy Theology of Consent on Amazon →
Close this page to return to your phrase in Embering.
Jonathan Foster’s phrases arrive one a day in Embering, a quiet app for reading a single phrase and letting it settle.
Get Embering