← Thomas Jay Oord
A Systematic Theology of Love

Must love, free to choose how

Chapter 3 · A Loving God · 2026

When I explored the definition of love earlier, I said love involves freedom. I also said various forces, factors, and actors limit a lover’s freedom. So, does saying the Spirit necessarily loves mean my love definition doesn’t apply to God? No, it does apply. God loves by necessity in one respect but freely in another. By nature, the Spirit must love, because love comes before choice in God. The divine nature limits what the Spirit can do, if “limit” is the right word for this logical entailment based upon a metaphysical reality. To the question whether the Spirit will love, the answer is God loves necessarily.

But God loves freely as an experiential free agent. As the Spirit moves moment by moment into an open future, deity freely chooses which forms and expressions of love to enact. God can’t be certain which will yield the best results, because the future isn’t something actual to be known, and creatures freely contribute to outcomes. To the question of how the Spirit loves in each moment, therefore, the answer would be that the Spirit freely chooses among the best options in relation to creation. In this sense, God loves freely.

Only in God does love necessarily come before free choice. After all, God is love.

From A Systematic Theology of Love: Volume 1: God and Creation (SacraSage Press, 2026). Quoted with the author's permission.

Buy A Systematic Theology of Love on Amazon →

← The Bible’s central themeAmipotence →

Close this page to return to your line in Embering.

Thomas Jay Oord's lines arrive one a day in Embering, a quiet app for reading a single line and letting it settle.

Get Embering