Love governs what God can do
When I say God “can’t” prevent evil, I mean God is unable to control people, other creatures, or circumstances that cause evil. Because God always loves and God’s love is uncontrolling, God cannot control. The God who can’t control others or circumstances can’t prevent evil singlehandedly. God’s love governs what God can do.
I can imagine the cries of some who read these statements. “Are you saying God is limited?” they wonder. “Who are you to limit God?” Despite what I’ve quoted from the Bible and theologians, the idea God cannot do something strikes many as heretical. “I have faith in an unlimited God,” they respond.
It’s important to recognize that I am not placing limits on God. Rather, God’s loving nature determines, shapes, or governs what God can do. External powers, natural laws, or Satan do not essentially limit God. Constraints to God’s power don’t come from outside.
God also doesn’t freely choose to be self-limited. God isn’t voluntarily deciding not to control others when doing so is possible. That’s the “God won’t” view. Rather than externally limited or voluntarily self-limited, God’s nature of love directs what God does.
…
Because God’s love self-gives and others-empowers, and because God loves all creatures from the most complex to the least, God cannot control. God loves everyone and everything, so God cannot control anyone or anything. This means a God of uncontrolling love cannot control evildoers to prevent their dastardly deeds.
We earlier read the passage from the Bible saying, “God cannot deny himself.” We now see how this applies to questions of God’s power and evil. If God’s nature is love and love never controls, God would have to deny his love to control others. But God can’t do that.
The limits to divine power come from God’s nature of love.
From God Can’t: How to Believe in God and Love after Tragedy, Abuse, or Other Evils (SacraSage Press, 2019). Quoted with the author's permission.
Close this page to return to your line in Embering.
Thomas Jay Oord's lines arrive one a day in Embering, a quiet app for reading a single line and letting it settle.
Get Embering