← Thomas Jay Oord
Open and Relational Theology

A timeless God

Chapter 2 · Open · 2021

The open view stands in stark contrast to theologies that say God dwells outside time or watches the parade of life from a primeval perch. Those views assume God is timeless. A timeless God has no experience of what it means to live moment by moment. A God who is in all respects timeless, in fact, can’t do what we normally think a deity does. He can’t respond to prayer, because “respond” implies a sequence of time. That God can’t continue creating, forgive past sins, or expect love to win. A timeless God can’t regret the Rwandan genocide, anticipate your next move in chess, or enjoy a joke’s surprising twist. A timeless God can’t do anything new or continue doing anything He did previously. Let me put a finer point on this. A God outside time can’t know the past as past or the future as possible, because He has only a single present, an eternal “now.” This deity can’t experientially understand past-tense phrases like “she died,” “World War II ended,” or “the L.A. Lakers used to be located in Minnesota.” There is no past tense to a God outside time.

…

And then there’s love. It’s hard to make sense of a timeless God giving and receiving in loving relationships. “Giving and receiving” assumes a sequence: first God gives and then receives. There’s no relational sequence in a timeless God.

Almost every form of love involves emotion. But God as described by timeless theologies is emotionless in response to what we do. The conventional God may blissfully contemplate Himself but has no emotional response to creatures. Without emotion for others, the timeless God can’t empathize with those who suffer or rejoice with those who celebrate. In sum: conventional theologies portray God as timeless, so they can’t portray God as a relational actor. These theologies don’t fit the way God is portrayed in sacred scriptures. They don’t fit our experiences as living beings. And they don’t fit the reality and ways of love. By contrast, an open and relational God experiences time’s flow.

From Open and Relational Theology: An Introduction to Life-Changing Ideas (SacraSage Press, 2021). Quoted with the author's permission.

Buy Open and Relational Theology on Amazon →

← The future is openA timefull God →

Close this page to return to your line in Embering.

Thomas Jay Oord's lines arrive one a day in Embering, a quiet app for reading a single line and letting it settle.

Get Embering