what we see others wanting
Mirror neurons indicate that we are born hardwired, we might say, with a hyper-awareness of others. This awareness is not something we outgrow; instead, we are engaged with it throughout life, albeit in ever more nuanced, complex, and often self-deluding ways. “We are constituted by the other,” Girard says, “by parents, authority figures, peers, rivals whom we internalize as models and who become the unconscious basis of our desires.” Whether it’s a childhood playmate, parent, teacher, next-door neighbor, or social media influencer, we are all in the process of having our desires mediated by the other.
Much of this can best be illustrated by pointing out the strategy of the marketing industry. The car commercial, for example, doesn’t necessarily tell us what we want to drive; it tells us what we see others wanting to drive. We notice their enjoyment, particularly when they are slightly more attractive or affluent (which means I notice this a lot). We see “the model’s” pleasure and long to make it our pleasure. We see their “wholeness” and long to make it our “wholeness.”
The importance of this idea—that we are constituted by the other—encouraged Girard to abandon any notion of the self-contained individual. He began to favor a more nuanced psychology of interdividuality, a neologism coined to emphasize that human beings are not autonomous individuals. “The true psychological reality,” as Oughourlian conceives it “is not situated within the individual but lies in the mysterious transparency of the relation between two persons. And this psychological relationship, this constant interaction, is entirely mimetic. It is characterized by the reciprocal movement of imitation and suggestion passing from one person to the other, a symmetrical movement that we forge and modify unceasingly.”
From Theology of Consent: Mimetic Theory in an Open and Relational Universe by Jonathan J. Foster (SacraSage Press, 2022), chapter I:1 Movement: Psychological and Spiritual. Quoted with the author's permission.
Buy Theology of Consent on Amazon →
Close this page to return to your phrase in Embering.
Jonathan Foster’s phrases arrive one a day in Embering, a quiet app for reading a single phrase and letting it settle.
Get Embering