violence inspires religion
“The mimetic nature reveals itself particularly in rituals. “Why,” as Girard asks, “does the ritual so often begin with a concocted disorder, with a deliberate simulated cultural crisis, and end with a victim who is expelled or ritually killed?” He answers himself: “The purpose is simply to reenact the mimetic crisis which leads to the scapegoat mechanism. The hope is that the re-enactment of this mechanism will reactivate its power of reconciliation.”
Again, all this is based on a profound misrecognition of what led the community to the brink of disaster in the first place. Still, the point is that ritualization perpetuates the myth of redemptive sacrifice; it saves the community from violence, but in the process institutionalizes collective murder and continually reinvigorates the surrogate-victim mechanism. As a result, one of Girard’s most significant insights is not that religion inspires violence; instead, violence inspires religion. And violence-inspired religion provides the foundation for culture:
As I said, in an effort to prevent frequent and unpredictable episodes of mimetic violence, acts of planned, controlled, mediated, periodical, ritualized surrogate violence were put in place. Ritual in this way becomes like a school because it repeats the same scapegoat mechanism over and over again on substitute victims. And since ritual is the resolution of a crisis, it always intervenes at points of crisis; it will always be there at the same point of the mimetic crisis. Therefore, ritual will turn into the institution that regulates any sort of crisis, like the crisis of adolescence and the rites of passage, like the crisis of death, which generates funeral rituals, like the crisis of disease, which generates ritual medicine.
From Theology of Consent: Mimetic Theory in an Open and Relational Universe by Jonathan J. Foster (SacraSage Press, 2022), chapter I:3 Religion: Scapegoat, Rinse, and Repeat. Quoted with the author's permission.
Buy Theology of Consent on Amazon →
Close this page to return to your phrase in Embering.
Jonathan Foster’s phrases arrive one a day in Embering, a quiet app for reading a single phrase and letting it settle.
Get Embering