to make her stronger
However, hold on. At the last minute, I will be given a chance to course-correct. I can still be welcomed back into the fold if only I repent and make one small amendment to my talk of love: that is, simply attach one of the aforementioned proper and biblical words to love. The truth I must align myself with, I am told, is, well, yes, love. Sort of? But really, it’s a Holy-love. They continue “with all heads bowed and all eyes closed and no one looking around the room,” but I cannot see the good news in all this. I cannot go forward to bow my knee, take the wine, say the prayer, recite the creed, do the dance, get baptized, or otherwise be indoctrinated into a theology of Omnipotent power. If love is required to report to anyone or anything, can it be called love?
I respectfully regard what the tradition has passed on to me. I genuinely consider the measure of comfort some of these ideas have provided people in previous and current generations. However, these are terms I no longer need prefixed to the nature of God. I am no longer looking to the faux essence of immutability to prop up the real essence of love. This would be like strapping Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson to the back of Mother Teresa to make her stronger. Weighted down by The Rock, Mother Teresa’s power would be rendered useless. This is what happens when we strap Holy to love— all of sudden love isn’t love unless it fits the shareholder’s definition of Holy, which if I’m not repeating myself here, is roughly synonymous with any of the other wild and wooly behemoths we’ve been trying to corral. Holy-love, or Immutable-love, or John Piper–love are, in principle, all roads leading to Rome, where, of course, Rome means thin and anemic definitions of love.
I am sighing over the redundancy of all these terms, or maybe I am breathing hard from my effort in gaining the winded edge of the continental divide. Still, either way, these hyphenated appellations seem to be one exercise after another in missing the point: a loving God is different from a God of love.
From Theology of Consent: Mimetic Theory in an Open and Relational Universe by Jonathan J. Foster (SacraSage Press, 2022), chapter II:1 The Universe in the Key of Relationality. Quoted with the author's permission.
Buy Theology of Consent on Amazon →
Close this page to return to your phrase in Embering.
Jonathan Foster’s phrases arrive one a day in Embering, a quiet app for reading a single phrase and letting it settle.
Get Embering