← Jonathan Foster
Theology of Consent

the mechanism is a lie

I:2 Scapegoating: The Currency of our Culture · p. 41 · 2022

It’s an ordinary story, a homeless non-Caucasian facing the juggernaut of empire in finance, politics, and religion. But what’s extraordinary is the way that, in this instance, it acted as a kind of rock that jammed up the machinery of scapegoating. This rock, what Jesus called the “cornerstone,” what the Apostle Paul called the “stumbling block,” is another term for the scapegoat, but in this case, it’s not tripping up the sinner as much as it’s tripping up the system of people claiming to be the arbiters of righteousness, holiness, and purity. It’s not tripping up the outsider; it’s tripping up the one who believes God needs outsiders.

I hope the reader accepts what the controllers of correctness so often refuse: it’s not a stumbling block because Jesus is a better sacrifice; it’s a stumbling block because it deconstructs the entire system of sacrifice. For Girard, Jesus’s cry, “It is finished,” is not his way to indicate that he finally convinced God to be loving. No, what is finished is the need for anyone to scapegoat. In other words, he became a scapegoat to end all scapegoating. Therefore, the message isn’t “Same Mechanism—Better Goat.” No, the message is, “The Mechanism is a Lie.” (Oh, and maybe, “Goats are Cute. Stop Killing Them.”)

The point: we are no longer required—even more, have never been required—to run through the mechanism’s sequence to gain peace. The extraordinary news the Girardian perspective opens us up to is that God doesn’t need victims; we do. God doesn’t use violence to gain peace; we do.

From Theology of Consent: Mimetic Theory in an Open and Relational Universe by Jonathan J. Foster (SacraSage Press, 2022), chapter I:2 Scapegoating: The Currency of our Culture. Quoted with the author's permission.

Buy Theology of Consent on Amazon →

← solidarity with the victimGod doesn’t need victims →

Close this page to return to your phrase in Embering.

Jonathan Foster’s phrases arrive one a day in Embering, a quiet app for reading a single phrase and letting it settle.

Get Embering