← Jonathan Foster
Theology of Consent

any length to be with us

III:1 Reflexive Sacrifice · p. 146 · 2022

Non-reflexive sacrifice has launched a thousand churches, the expressed intent of which is to proclaim freedom to the captives, though their “freedom” is simply an updated way to hold people captive to the message of non-reflexive sacrifice. But this is our idea, not God’s. We are the ones who killed Jesus. We did so because we are so often incapable of accessing peace outside of violence, which is to say we are unwilling to be peaceful, for the peace that comes by way of violence is not peace.

The great revelation of the murder of Jesus is not that God has now been avenged; it’s that love will go to any length to be with us. When faced with the choice between living within the parameters of a violent system and death, Jesus chose the latter. He did so, apparently, because to do anything else would have been a compromise with violence. I don’t imagine Jesus stared at the ceiling at night, dreaming up ways to be murdered in the hopes of gaining savior status posthumously. “The person who seeks to be martyred in this way,” as Alison says, “is still very much formed by the violent desires of the world: needing a peculiar form of victory over your enemies. John stresses in particular Jesus’s freedom with relation to his hour and the way in which he was laying down his life of his own accord.” No, what led Jesus to death was his extraordinary commitment to life.

I admit, there is a way to read the sacred text and conclude that God needed Jesus to die. Many have arrived at this conclusion. But viewing all this in light of open and relational theology and Girard’s mimetic theory helps us see the violent instability of such a conclusion, for it’s an unstable community that builds its world around a God in need of placating. How could one ever be assured that the sacrifice really “did the trick?”

From Theology of Consent: Mimetic Theory in an Open and Relational Universe by Jonathan J. Foster (SacraSage Press, 2022), chapter III:1 Reflexive Sacrifice. Quoted with the author's permission.

Buy Theology of Consent on Amazon →

← the first-responder kind of wayat-one-ment →

Close this page to return to your phrase in Embering.

Jonathan Foster’s phrases arrive one a day in Embering, a quiet app for reading a single phrase and letting it settle.

Get Embering